Easy Marinated Tomatoes (+ Leftover Soup!)

These marinated tomatoes are one of those quietly brilliant recipes that don't scream for attention - but once they're on the table, they disappear fast. Juicy, herby, gently tangy, with just enough sweetness to balance slightly green tomatoes, this is the kind of dish that tastes like late summer and early fall all at once.

 

 

If you grow your own tomatoes, this recipe is especially satisfying. It's a great way to use a mix of perfectly ripe tomatoes and those stubborn, slightly green ones that refuse to turn red before the season ends. But even store-bought tomatoes benefit from a good marinade, and this one is simple, flexible, and deeply flavorful.

 

Serve them as a side, pile them onto toast, spoon them over grilled fish, or turn the leftovers into soup the next day. This is one of those "how did I not always do this?" recipes.

 

More tomato recipes

• Berbere chicken
• Roasted tomato soup
• Extra veggie tomato bolognese

 

Why you'll love this recipe

 

Marinated tomatoes show up in many cuisines, especially around the Mediterranean, where simple ingredients are allowed to shine. Oil, acid, herbs, and time do most of the work. This version leans slightly Nordic in spirit - lots of fresh herbs, a clean acidity, and a focus on good produce rather than heavy seasoning.

 

They're especially popular in late summer when tomatoes are abundant, but this recipe also works beautifully in early fall, when you're dealing with a mix of ripe and under-ripe fruit from the garden.

 

These tomatoes pair particularly well with:

• Grilled meat or fish
• Toasted bread or focaccia 
• Soft cheeses like cream cheese, ricotta, or burrata
• Simple green salads, for example switch out the tomatoes in this rosemary chicken salad!
• Cold cuts or cured meats

 

 

They're also surprisingly versatile - not just a side dish, but a building block for other meals!

 

Ingredients

 

1. Tomatoes - A mix of ripe and slightly green tomatoes gives the best balance. The ripe ones bring sweetness and juice, while the green ones add freshness and structure. Slicing the green tomatoes thinner helps them soften in the marinade.
2. Extra virgin olive oil - This is the backbone of the marinade. Use a good-quality oil - here you'll taste it.
3. Balsamic or apple cider vinegar - Adds acidity and depth. Balsamic brings a little richness and sweetness, while apple cider vinegar keeps things brighter and sharper. I usually use the latter here.
4. Garlic - Just one large clove, finely chopped. Enough to add warmth without overpowering the tomatoes.
5. Honey or sugar - This is key when using green tomatoes. A small amount balances acidity and rounds out the flavor.
6. Fresh herbs - Thyme and oregano add earthiness, while chives and parsley keep it fresh and green. This combination gives depth without stealing focus from the tomatoes.
7. Salt and freshly ground pepper - Essential for drawing out juices and seasoning everything properly.
8. Chili flakes (optional) - Highly recommended. A gentle heat makes the tomatoes even more addictive.

 

 

Instructions

 

Prepare tomatoes: Start by preparing the tomatoes. Slice the ripe ones into wedges or thick slices, depending on their size. Slice the slightly green tomatoes thinner - this helps them soften and absorb the marinade more effectively.

 

 

Make the marinade: In a bowl, mix together the olive oil, vinegar, garlic, honey or sugar, fresh herbs, salt, pepper, and chili flakes if using. Taste the marinade before adding the tomatoes and adjust seasoning if needed - it should taste herby, tangy, and salty.

 

 

Mix tomatoes with marinade: Place the tomatoes in a shallow bowl or serving dish and pour the marinade over them. Gently toss or turn the tomatoes so everything is evenly coated. Try not to break them up too much, especially the ripe ones.

 

Marinate: Let the tomatoes marinate at room temperature for at least 30 minutes before serving. If your green tomatoes are very firm, letting them sit for 1-2 hours will give a better texture and deeper flavor.

 

Serve: Before serving, give them one last gentle toss and adjust seasoning if needed. A sprinkle of fresh herbs on top is always nice.

 

 

Substitutions

 

• No fresh thyme or oregano? Use one or the other, or substitute with another herb, like basil.
• Honey can be replaced with sugar or maple syrup.
• Apple cider vinegar can be swapped for red wine vinegar or white wine vinegar.
• If you don't like garlic raw, reduce the amount slightly or let the marinade sit for 10 minutes before adding tomatoes to mellow it out. It can also be omitted.

 

Variations

 

Toast with whipped cream cheese
Serve the marinated tomatoes on toasted bread with whipped cream cheese mixed with olive oil, salt, pepper, and Aleppo chili flakes. This makes an excellent lunch or appetizer - and trust me - it disappears fast.

 

More heat
Add extra chili flakes or a pinch of cayenne to the marinade for extra punch.

 

 

Mediterranean style
Add olives or a small amount of finely chopped red onion and cucumber.

 

Herb swap
Lean more heavily into basil and parsley for a softer, sweeter profile.

 

Turn it into soup (the next day)
Blend leftover marinated tomatoes with water, salt, sugar, and chili powder. Warm gently and serve with bread. Shockingly good. Although, I'd make sure to double the recipe to make sure I had enough for the leftover soup!

 

Here's how you turn it into a lovely leftover soup:

 

1. Blend the marinated tomatoes with water (or broth), salt, sugar, and chili powder together in a pot.
2. Gently heat the mixture while stirring until it's warmed through and well combined.
3. Taste as you go - adjust the salt, sugar, or spices as needed.

 

Adding the seasoning before heating allows the flavors to meld together nicely during warming, but it's important to taste at the end because heat can intensify the salt and spices.

 

Per 3 cups marinated tomatoes:

 

• 1-1¼ cups water or vegetable broth
• ½-¾ teaspoon salt (begin with less)
• ¼ teaspoon sugar (or to taste)
• 1-1½ teaspoon chili powder (or to taste) I use my homemade Mexican chili powder!

 

Makes about 1 serving. Hence why we should double the recipe! The images are of a doubled recipe. 

 

It would be so good with some super easy quesadillas!

 

Equipment

 

You don't need much for this recipe. A sharp knife is important for clean tomato slices, especially if they're very ripe. A shallow bowl or platter works better than a deep one, as it allows the tomatoes to marinate evenly.

 

If you plan to blend leftovers into soup, a regular blender or immersion blender works perfectly.

 

Storage

 

These tomatoes keep well in the fridge for up to 2 days. Store them in an airtight container.

 

They're excellent the next day - softer, more deeply flavored, and perfect for blending into soup or spooning over toast. Bring them to room temperature before serving for the best flavor.

 

 

Expert tips

 

My top tips for the best marinated tomatoes include:

• Always season generously - tomatoes need salt.
• Slice green tomatoes thinner than ripe ones to soften them.
• Let them marinate at room temperature, not in the fridge. When tomatoes are cold (like straight from the fridge), their cell structure tighten slightly. At room temperature, they soften just enough to absorb the marinade more effectively, giving you a richer flavor profile. 
• Taste and adjust before serving - tomatoes vary a lot in sweetness and acidity.
• Don't skip the herbs; they make the dish.
• Double the recipe so you can also make the leftover soup.

 

Recipe FAQs

Enjoy!

Did you like this recipe? Here are more brunch dishes I think you would love:

I'd love to hear your thoughts. Comment below or tag me @thegingerwithspice on Instagram. And don't forget to Pin it for later! To make sure you're never missing another recipe, please feel free to subscribe to my newsletter. 

As thanks, you will receive a free e-cookbook Travels Through the Seasons, with many delicious recipes from around the world that suit different seasons of the year. 

To keep the blog up and running this post may contain affiliate links, it will be at no extra cost to you, please read the disclosure for more information.

 

Print

Recipe